Our quest for self-direction and autonomy is described by researchers at the University of Rochester. The scientists there developed Self-Determinant Theory (SDT), which states that for people to grow psychologically, they need:
- Autonomy
- Competence
- Connectedness
Autonomy is the feeling that people are in control of their own behavior. People feel empowered to choose action rather than be told what choice to make. Autonomy includes the knowledge that whatever action a person takes, will directly affect their life.
Our Quest for Self Direction
Competence involves the desire for control, which leads people to master tasks that affect their lives. The better people master needed skills, the more they can influence their situation. As people begin to experience this feeling of control, they strive to increase their mastery of more skills to exert even greater control of their lives.
Connectedness is the sense of closeness and attachment people feel to one another. As part of Abraham Maslow’s theory of the Hierarchy of Needs, the feeling of belonging lays the foundation for self-actualization and autonomy. People meet this need through social connections and showing care for others.
Intrinsic versus Extrinsic Rewards
Self-determinant theory also takes into account different types of rewards and motivators. Intrinsic rewards and motivation are part of autonomy. When a person finds satisfaction, or reward, internally because of something they’ve done, it motivates them, again internally, to achieve more.
External rewards can hinder or boost autonomy. Too many external rewards and punishments take away autonomy because they create a framework where someone or something else is in control. However, some external rewards, like praise for a job well done, boost confidence and lead to greater competence and autonomy.
A Meaningful Life
Meaningfulness is a fundamental part of a worthwhile life. People need to feel that their life has meaning and purpose. A lack of meaning in life is associated with depression, suicide, and mortality.
A study by Harvard University also showed that having purpose and meaning can provide longer life. In this study, researchers gave each nursing home resident a plant. Half the residents were told they needed to care for the plant, while half were told the staff would look after it.
The group that cared for the plant themselves lived longer than those who did not care for the plant, even when the results were adjusted for age and medical conditions. Purpose and meaningfulness are found through autonomy and lead to a better, longer life.
Many of the ancient roles that provided autonomy, competence, and connectedness in today’s society have changed. Humans no longer value hunting skills as a way to provide for themselves and their families. Instead, daily work has replaced the hunter or gatherer role. A study in the Journal of Occupational Health Psychology found that meaningful work contributes to positive well-being.
An emphasis on meaningful work has become the focus of vocational and career counseling. According to a Journal of Counseling Psychology study, this emphasis works to promote both employee satisfaction and productivity. Employers are finding that by highlighting the meaningfulness of the work, employees feel more connected to their purpose and produce better results.
Paying work is not the only route to autonomy and meaningfulness, however. Some people find satisfaction in doing a less than autonomous paying job because it provides them with the means to use their free time to pursue their life purpose. Their purpose may involve family, pursuing their interests, or volunteering.
Self-direction is based on autonomy, competence, and connectedness. Today, society offers various routes to fill this basic human need through work, family, or volunteer activities.